Tudor Archives - Page 2 of 5 - Exquisite Timepieces
iconHome Blog / Tudor / Page 2

Category: Tudor

tudor black bay 36 review

Tudor Black Bay 36 Review (Read BEFORE You Buy!)

Alex DeVane

March 21, 2025

Tudor has a history of not getting the respect it deserves from the industry. In the ’90s, many viewed them as cheap Rolex copycats, often overlooking what they brought to the table and instead favoring other Rolex-like companies such as Seiko and Tag Heuer, which seemed to offer far more originality and unique characteristics to their pieces than anything Tudor was doing at the time. This ultimately led to the brand leaving the US in 1996. 

In this article, we will be looking at how Tudor made their valiant return to the US after discovering themselves, particularly focusing on how the Black Bay became one of their most iconic pieces and is arguably the most sought-after Tudor on the market today. 

bot-only-imagebot-only-image

History 

Tudor Black Bay 36

In 2013, Tudor returned to the US, this time straying away from copycats and perfecting their own designs, slowly evolving into the brand we know today. First introduced in 2017, the Black Bay 36 was originally offered in black, with a 41mm version alongside it.

Being part of the Black Bay line, neither of these pieces could match the water resistance found on the divers, but 150M deep is still more than enough resistance for the average wearer. Plus, people liked the Black Bay line for other reasons.

Eventually, the navy blue variant came into the spotlight in 2018 and was immediately looked upon with favorable nostalgia from those reminiscent of pieces like the Tudor Subs from the 70s and 80s. The 36mm version seemed to enthrall fans, sharing many similarities with 36mm Rolex’s but having just enough personality to give itself a well-respected name. 

Getting a closer look at this watch was a treat, and I was left exceedingly impressed with the design choices Tudor made to set them apart from the competition.

While in the past, their originality might have been questionable, I think it’s safe to say Tudor has redeemed itself for previous errors by flipping the watch industry on its head and putting in the extra work to make themselves one of the most well-respected brands on the market. 

Case

Every review I’ve seen of this watch raves about how this is one of the most well-balanced and properly proportioned cases of all time.

And I must say, after firsthand experience, I would have to wholeheartedly agree. While the Black Bay comes in three sizes (32, 36, 41), the 36mm is the true star of the show, which is what we will be focusing on today.

While I haven’t dealt personally with the two other sizes, the common consensus is that the 32mm is a tad cramped, and the 41mm is a bit spaced out, leaving the 36mm to find the perfect median.

It is worth pointing out that by today’s standards, 36mm is considered on the smaller side of sports watches, which may leave those of you with larger wrists with no other option. I have no doubt that the 41mm can satisfy all of your needs should that be the only size that fits; today, we are simply focusing on the 36mm in particular. So, let’s dive in.

The case features impeccable finishing, which really puts into perspective how much detail is intertwined with this piece. It has slab sides polished to effortlessly catch light and gleam like unblemished glass.

Being that it’s a thinner watch, the slab sides are proportioned to accommodate the rest of the sides and subtly do their part, taking extra care not to feel too clunky.

The crown breaks through the stainless steel surface, imposing itself as one of the signature trademarks of the Black Bay line. The rose logo is a subtle throwback to one of Tudor’s earlier heritage models, which plays on the nostalgic strings even more. 

The fixed bezel comes highly polished and glistens brighter than the radial brushing of the lugs, reinforcing the aesthetic with a nice contrast.

The sapphire lens fits the bright polishing, shining just as bright under certain lighting conditions, causing the watch to shimmer on your wrist, and the closed case back keeps everything nice and tight, offering flawless protection. 

Dial

Each dial color is beautiful in its own right, but the semi-gloss blue dial is extremely eye-catching. Again, like the sizing, the Tudor Black Bay finds the perfect median concerning the shade of blue—not too dark and not too light, seemingly transforming on the wrist when exposed to certain light.

The indices are slightly raised, standing 0.5mm tall, giving an extra layer of detail while highlighting the polished sides that also reflect light. The indices caught my eye because they are a mixture of shapes.

At the 12:00, there is a narrow triangle facing downwards; at the 3:00 6:00, and 9:00, slender rectangles disrupt the circular pattern, providing a unique sense of elegance and a nice geometric aesthetic that is extremely satisfying to look at.

Each index also comes equipped with a white lume that glows a low green in the dark, helping with nocturnal visibility. It also features a sapphire crystal up top, which pretty much guarantees that the Black Bay will not scratch under most conditions. 

The “TUDOR” text is in a perfect position, not too large to steal any attention but just noticeable enough to give you something else to look at. Below, the “ROTOR SELF-WINDING” text is curved, which kind of looks like a little smiley face.

The elegant, snowflake hands sweep over all of this, combining a straightforward, slender minute hand with a diamond-shaped hour hand that’s a great deal fatter. The second hand is very subtle despite the diamond-shaped lume plot towards the tip. 

I can understand how people tend to scoff at snowflake hands, but I feel they match the setting that Tudor is trying to create and stand out as one of the most dynamic features of this piece. In my opinion, it’s rare for snowflake hands not to hit the spot.

They are highly legible and fit the tone of this watch perfectly. Plus, they give a blocky feel that is actually quite charming to look at, complementing the geometric shapes of the indices. 

Movement

The ETA 2824 movement powers the Black Bay. Today, most Tudor watches have shifted to in-house movement, but the Black Bay is one of the only remaining pieces that still uses an outsourced movement.

Tudor has actually modified the ETA 2824 to keep things as accurate as possible. The movements are regulated to COSC standards but do not go through the certification process, causing Tudor to slightly improve upon the original movement, allowing the Black Bay to tick at a resounding -1 sec/day. 

Straps

I recommend choosing the oyster-style bracelet, though you can opt for the watch on a strap. Not only is the bracelet cheaper than going out and buying another strap, but it looks better, too. The fit and finish is excellent, mimicking the bracelet with brushed surfaces and flanked sides.

The strap starts at 19mm and finishes at 16mm when it meets the clasp. The clasp is fairly wide, measuring 17mm, and has a vintage-looking taper that makes the watch quite comfortable to wear.

The Tudor shield shines on the back of the clasp with three positions for micro-adjusting the bracelet. While researching what others thought of this piece, I noticed a common theme of people being a little annoyed with how few fitting options there are.

19mm is a fairly uncommon size, so you may end up searching for bracelets that accommodate your wrist more comfortably. It’s also worth pointing out that the Tudor does not currently offer a half-link option for the Black Bay, making the search for perfect comfort a little more complicated. 

Of course, this is a minor complaint. The curves of the bracelet and case still make for a smooth fit, so, depending on your wrist size, you may suffer no problems at all. 

On Wrist Experience

To put it frankly, this watch is a delight to wear. It’s not perfect—nothing is—but it’s going to be difficult to find anyone with any major complaints.

Some advice I will give is that if you have a wrist smaller than 6.5 inches, you will have virtually no problems at all finding a perfect fit, but those of you with significantly larger wrists may need to size up. The oyster case (in most instances) guarantees an esteemed level of comfort, and—I’ll say it again—the proportions are genuinely some of the best I’ve ever seen.

People will undoubtedly be drawn to the watch’s slim measurements, but to call this watch slim itself feels wrong.

It manages to do something I’ve never seen before; it disguises itself as a thinner, more luxurious watch, but on the wrist, it makes its presence known in the best of ways, coming alive as a true dive watch.

What Tudor does is combine all the intricate details and measurements with a simple yet effective aesthetic, giving their wearers quite the surprise when they find out the Black Bay offers so much more than they previously thought. Numbers don’t always give the full picture.

The 36mm strikes a perfect balance between elegance and sportiness, securing a spot in Tudor’s collection as a truly timeless piece. 

The Black Bay essentially resides on two different sides of the spectrum. On one end, it oozes in comfort and elegance, making it the perfect watch for any formal occasion. On the other hand, it is a true dive watch, dubbing it fit for day-to-day wear with authentic utilitarian roots.

This gives us (once again) a perfect combination. Realistically, you never have to take this watch off, no matter where you go. It’s not one of those fragile pieces that you always have to worry about getting damaged, nor is it one of those clunky bricks that are virtually indestructible but look like an entire cinder block on your wrist.

The theme for the Black Bay seems to be finding the perfect median, and it has truly impressed me with how much it was able to do just that. 

Pricing

You can find the Tudor Black Bay 36 from Tudor authorized dealers, like Exquisite Timepieces. We only ship to the US and are authorized dealers, ensuring a 5-year warranty directly from Tudor. A brand new Black Bay 36 can be picked up for $4,050 USD. Pre-owned pieces usually range from 3 to 4k, depending on the condition of the watch. 

Conclusion 

This watch is beautiful; it fits great, and its versatility allows for constant wear, which is great when considering the price of watches like these. Tudor has indeed come a long way since departing the American market in 1996.

They have forged a new name for themselves, one that is now known for creative, original pieces that not only stand out in and of themselves but define the respective genre they belong to. In my opinion, the Black Bay is a perfect introduction to luxury timepieces.

Relatively cheap compared to other watches in the market, I would consider the Black Bay a jack of all trades and pretty much guarantee that anyone who at least respects the watch world will find something they adore on this piece. 

Tudor is one of the most consistent brands of the modern day. With how much they had to go to get to where they are, it’s going to be difficult to find a piece that falls short of the standard they have set for themselves.

The Black Bay is a treasure, and some already consider it a classic, but as the years go on, this piece will undoubtedly take its rightful place in history books as one of the most appealing watches of all time.

tudor black bay 54 review

Another name that speaks for itself, Tudor comes with a long history in luxury watchmaking. Even though I don’t have many of them in my collection, anything new in their catalog always demands a second look.

When it comes to the Tudor Black Bay 54, you can tell it’s built for those who are adept to the ocean life. Offering a waterproof depth of 200 meters and great visibility to match, it’s an all-encompassing and affordable divers watch.

bot-only-imagebot-only-image

While I’m a stickler for the engineering in functionality, beauty and ensign equally matter with any high-end timepiece. This article focuses on the Tudor Black Bay 54, offering an in-depth review from every angle.

The Watch’s Backstory

Tudor Black Bay 54

Acting as a focal point to the modern Black Bay collection from Tudor, I can tell the BB 54 is pretty heritage-inspired. I initially determined this in their choice of using 54, alluding to their Oyster Prince Submariner from 1954.

This is an icon of a dive watch from the brand, and it didn’t take long for me to recognize other aspects that are built-in as a tribute.

I know this isn’t for everyone, but you can find historical references in the watch’s relatively vintage design as well. One might argue with this, but if you know anything about the background of Tudor watch design, the small details tend to stand out.

Regardless of the watchmaker, I’m always a huge fan of blending the old with the new. Although the Tudor Black Bay 54 was released back in March of 2023, it still stands as a fan favorite for many people. For me, what keeps this watch in my usual rotation is its neutrality, with a hint of bold contrast coming from the dial. 

Overall, it’s a new staple in the history of Tudor diver’s watches. You can find other Black Bay designs since the collection’s release. Black Bay 54 leads the way not only because it’s somewhat new but also due to its specific inspirations from the brand’s past.

Starting With the Case

All around, you get the strength and beauty of 316L steel. What sells me is the combination of a polished and satin finish as well. I can understand how looks alone handle a lot of the decision-making, but it’s crucial to look at all of the specs.

The case on the Black Bay 54 comes with a 37mm diameter and 11.3mm thickness, and it’s 46mm lug to lug. Don’t worry; you aren’t permanently bound to the strap either, as the lug width is only 20mm, making it more than compatible with other options.

Aside from that, the bezel on this case is pretty seamless. It’s unidirectional and is crafted with an aluminum insert. I noticed there aren’t any minute graduations on it either, which makes it all look even more uniform.

It’s unfortunate you don’t get an exhibition case back with this watch, but you do get the durability and beauty of stainless steel. However, I do salute the brand for thinking of this small detail, as the screw-in design is great for waterproofing.

Even though the crystal choice here is somewhat standard, domed sapphire plays a lot more into the look of the case than you might think. I’m a fan of this choice as it helps to make the watch case look more compact.

You won’t ever struggle with the crown, thankfully. It’s also stainless steel, and although it’s a screw-down, you won’t ever find water making its way in.

I know there are many reasons as to why Tudor is so popular, but for me, it’s their approach to the finer details. Knowing that they’re one step ahead of what I’m looking for makes me even more satisfied with having one of my own.

Looking Further Into the Dial

Tudor Black Bay 54 Dial

Revered for its vintage take on the style, the dial on the Black Bay 54 features gilt accents and the perfect amount of contrast. If you’re familiar with the watchmaker at all, then some of the dial’s features will feel a bit familiar.

More specifically, it’s the classic snowflake hour and minute hands that stand out the most to me. I can see how they’d seem bulky to some wearer, but readability is what’s important here. It’s a common feature with diver’s watches, as hands and markers need to stand out.

In the same vein, this doesn’t take away from the watch’s elegant style. I’d also like to point out the lollipop style of the seconds hand, which is a nice nod to an old-school look.

You may not immediately notice the variation with the indices as well. They’re equally bold and offer a variation of circles, rectangles, and triangles.

Of course, you can expect plenty of lume to be included as the watch is intended for low-light conditions. To help add more contrast to the gilt accents, every bit of text on the watch comes in gold as well. 

I can agree that the hands and indices are rather bulky, but this doesn’t make the whole watch seem overly large by any means. The domed sapphire and efficient use of space creates the perfect balance between design and functionality.

I think it’s also important to highlight the cream-colored look of the lume in daylight conditions. This does an impressive job of adding rich color variety among the dark dial and stylish gold accents.

The Heart of the Black Bay 54

As much as I like to look at the BB 54, what makes it all function is even more important than the visuals. The watch works off the Calibre MT5400, which is an in-house movement and a collaboration with the help of Kenissi.

Using a bi-directional rotor system, the movement is able to deliver efficient and accurate automatic winding. The 70-hour power reserve is a common feature, but definitely an important one to have with a divers watch.

I personally got pretty curious about the frequency of this movement, as the fine print always matters. The movement promises 28,800 vibrations per second, which tells me it shouldn’t have any issues being accurate with the time.

Better yet, the watch is Chronometer-certified, which adds an extra layer of reliability alongside -2/+4 seconds per day,

Although the inner parts of this movement can seem microscopic, they’re made from quality materials across the board. For example, you stainless steel and tungsten materials.

Combined with precise craftsmanship, you get durability, efficiency, and beauty all in one. Low maintenance, ease of use, and long-term reliability are what Tudor was going for here.

The watchmaker considered performance above all else, as they should from my standpoint. I’ve seen numerous luxury watches preserve visuals over long-term functionality, which always kind of rubs me the wrong the way. Tudor makes it obvious where the beauty lies, with most of the highlights being in the functionality from my point of view. 

Reviewing the Strap Options

It’s clear why most people would just go with the uniform stainless steel look, but this isn’t your only option.

The Black Bay 54 also comes in a rubber strap variety if you’re looking for a little more contrast and security. Whether you’re in or out of the water, the rubber strap offers all the secure placement you need throughout the day.

I have personally never been a huge fan of rubber straps, so the stainless steel was an easy choice for me. At the same time, part of what pulls me in this direction is their vintage choice with the three-link design.

The T-fit clasp makes adjustments a breeze, and I’m a huge fan of the fact that they include five adjustment positions. All of this can be done without the need for additional tools. Considering efficiency like this is something that’ll make the watch a daily wear for me.

You might not notice it at first, but their choice of ceramic ball bearings is part of what makes the adjustments feel so smooth.

In short, that stainless steel strap feels durable and secure without weighing you down. I like that the T-fit clasp design is part of the rubber strap as well, and it’s a more lightweight choice if it matters that much to you.

While you won’t get any additional straps purchasing a Black Bay 54, it won’t be hard to find something to swap it out with. Focusing on comfort: how a watch case and strap feel around my wrist will guide my decision-making a lot. 

The strap definitely makes this watch feel like a cohesive timepiece where the weight is balanced just right. Tudor’s are becoming more popular for my daily wears, and even though I’m not big on the water, the comfort and style of this watch are hard for me to ignore.

In my opinion, Tudor kept it simple and straightforward when it comes to the strap. The design makes it look and feel great and offers all the adjustments you might need.

This also makes it a great choice for a variety of wrist sizes, both big and small. Even though watch customizations aren’t impossible, I know I don’t want to take that route if I don’t have to.

For Daily Wear and Special Occasions

Tudor is known for its approach to luxury just as much as it is for functionality. You can see this in quite a few of their watch models, but the BB 54 stood out to me for more than one reason. For starters, almost every watch I purchase comes with the features I need in a daily wear.

The Black Bay 54 has all of that and much more on top of that. How it feels is my second focal point, and Tudor hit the nail on the head with this one. It doesn’t feel bulky or unbalanced from any angle, and it doesn’t tire out my wrist throughout the day.

Over time, I was able to determine the sweet spot for comfortable wear with this watch on wrists ranging from 5.5″ to 7″. However, the flexibility in the strap makes it more than suitable for a broad range of wrist sizes.

It’s pretty adaptable compared to many other timepieces on the market. I’ve made it pretty clear that the watch feels great, but the looks can’t be ignored, either. It’s a blend of beauty, and neutrality is the icing on the cake for what I like to wear on a daily basis.

I’m usually more prone to lean toward bold dials as well. The minor gold contrast is more than enough to ensure the watch isn’t too boring without distracting from the main colorway at the same time. I believe balance makes most things in life much better, and Tudor executed this perfectly with the design of the Black Bay 54.

Although I understand personal preference can play into a lot of these details, the craftsmanship from Tudor is hard to argue with. As I always like to say, trying it for yourself is important, but that means you need to understand what kind of investment you’re walking into.

Considering the Cost

After spending a little time with the Black Bay 54, I started to stress over how much the asking price was going to be. Once I started to feel like I wanted one of my own, it was time to dig into the retail price.

It was a breath of fresh air to discover I wasn’t going to have to go bankrupt to have one of my own. From a reputable retailer, you can find the Black Bay 54 from Tudor retailed at $4,050. Anyone in the industry understands price points will vary, but you also don’t want to be duped into overpaying.

There’s also nothing wrong with considering a previously owned BB 54. If you’re looking to save a little, taking this route can cost anywhere from $2,850 to the higher end of $3,000. It’s pretty easy to source the cost of luxury watches nowadays, but due diligence is crucial to ensure you’re getting a fair number. 

This is a great example of why Exquisite Timepieces has been my go-to since day one. They get straight to the point on what matters most and keep the fluff out of the process, which makes the whole process a lot less confusing.

Part of this also has to do with the retailer you’re working with. Industry experience and reputation matter just as much as product selection and retail price. Personally, this tends to be harder to find than I expect. Working with a retailer you can rely on for the long term is where you want to start before anything else.

The Bottom Line

You won’t have a hard time sourcing a Tudor Black Bay 54 of your own, but you don’t want to pick one up from just anywhere. For those searching for professionalism and a life-long use case, the best BB 54 is a great example of what the best of both worlds looks like.

I have owned Tudor watches in the past, but this model is now sitting at the top of my list after putting one on for myself. If you think the Black Bay 54 sounds like a great choice for you, never hesitate to reach out to us at Exquisite Timepieces for the information, support, and price points you can rely on.

longines vs tudor

If someone asked me to name some watch brands that perfectly straddle the line between accessibility and luxury, two names would instantly spring to mind: Longines and Tudor. These Swiss powerhouses epitomize what it means to create high-quality, refined timepieces that don’t demand you empty your bank account. 

With their use of premium materials, robust Swiss-made movements, and a commitment to precision, both brands have carved out a unique space in the watch world, one that’s as approachable as it is aspirational.

bot-only-imagebot-only-image

But what really makes this comparison fascinating is just how much these two brands have in common. Take the Longines Spirit and the Tudor Black Bay, for example. 

Both exude a vintage-inspired, tool-watch charm that pays homage to the golden age of watchmaking while offering modern reliability and style. And yet, despite their similarities, each brand brings its own design DNA and rich history to the table, making them distinct in their own right.

Ultimately, choosing between Longines and Tudor comes down to personal preference. Do you gravitate toward Longines’ elegant heritage, or does Tudor’s bold, adventure-ready spirit speak to you more? 

Either way, you’re in good hands. So, without further ado, let’s dive into the histories, design philosophies, and standout collections of these two iconic brands to help you make the best choice for your wrist.

Brand Heritage

Let’s talk about Longines, a name that’s been around since 1832. It all started in the quiet Swiss town of Saint-Imier when Auguste Agassiz opened a little watch workshop. 

Fast forward a few decades, and his nephew Ernest Francillon came on board, turning that small operation into something much bigger.

He centralized production, something that was a bold move back then, and stamped the brand with the winged hourglass logo we still see today, officially putting Longines on the map. 

What really set Longines apart in its early days was its desire to push boundaries. They have secured many “firsts” in their arsenal, like the first flyback chronograph, the first rotating bezel, and even the first dual-time-zone watch. 

Longines also revolutionized sports timing, becoming the go-to watchmaker for precision timekeeping in equestrian sports, skiing, and even aviation. 

The latter is one of Longines’ biggest claims to fame, having worked with aviation legends like Charles Lindbergh, who collaborated with Longines to create the iconic Hour Angle watch. It’s why you’ll often find so many celebrating Longines modern-day pilot’s watch collection.

Nowadays, Longines is part of the Swatch Group and is still producing watches that blend timeless design with modern tech, making it a favorite for anyone who wants a piece of Swiss heritage at an affordable price.

For Tudor, things started a little later. The Swiss watchmaker’s story kicked off in 1926 when Hans Wilsdorf, the mastermind behind Rolex, decided to create a brand that would offer the same durability, precision, and reliability as Rolex but at a more accessible price point. Tudor nailed that balance by using Rolex’s iconic cases and bracelets but keeping costs down with off-the-shelf movements. 

Tudor quickly built a reputation for toughness. Their partnership with the French Navy cemented their status as the go-to for dive watches, starting with the Submariner in 1954.

And let’s not forget 1969, when Tudor decided to do something bold with the iconic “snowflake” hands. Even today, these broad, super legible hands are what help set Tudor apart from their big brother, Rolex. 

Modern Tudor continues to embrace its legacy while pushing boundaries. The brand redefined itself in 2010 with the launch of the Tudor Heritage line, which brought vintage-inspired models like the Black Bay and Pelagos to a new generation of collectors. 

Notably, Tudor has stepped out of Rolex’s shadow by offering its own in-house movements, combining precision engineering with rugged aesthetics.

Model Variety

When it comes to sheer variety, Longines is tough to beat. They have a watch for pretty much every occasion and every type of wearer, whether you’re looking for a sleek dress watch, a rugged pilot’s watch, a sporty dive watch, or something that strikes a balance between these styles. Longines splits its lineup into two main categories: the Classic collection and the Sport collection. 

The Classic collection is where you’ll find their most timeless and elegant watches. For men and women who appreciate understated sophistication, the DolceVita series is a standout. 

Its rectangular cases and Art Deco vibes make it perfect for formal occasions or as an everyday dress watch. Then there’s the Master Collection, which is packed with complications like moon phases, chronographs, and power reserve indicators all wrapped in a refined package. 

On the other hand, the Sport collection is where Longines flexes its versatility. The HydroConquest is a modern dive watch with impressive water resistance and bold designs, perfect for those who love the outdoors. 

For fans of aviation history, the Spirit collection channels the brand’s ties to pioneering aviators with vintage-inspired tool watches. And if you’re looking for something sleek but sporty, the Conquest line covers everything from casual wear to sports timing. 

With such a broad range of styles, sizes, and configurations, including a significant number of watches designed specifically for women, Longines truly offers something for everyone.

Tudor’s lineup, by contrast, is more streamlined but still covers all the essentials. The brand’s modern success is built largely around the Black Bay collection, which has grown into a versatile family of dive watches inspired by Tudor and Rolex history. 

It all started with models like the classic Black Bay Fifty-Eight, but the collection now includes GMTs, chronographs, and even dressier models like the Black Bay 31/36/39/41.

These watches combine vintage-inspired designs with modern technology and are perfect for those who want a balance between ruggedness and elegance. 

If you’re looking for a pure dive watch, Tudor’s Pelagos series delivers. This line is designed for serious underwater use, offering advanced features like helium escape valves and lightweight titanium cases.

The Ranger, on the other hand, is all about adventure, channeling the rugged spirit of the Rolex Explorer with its simple, no-nonsense design. 

For something a bit more dressy, the 1926 collection offers classic styles for men and women, while the Clair de Rose line caters specifically to women with a refined, elegant touch.

Finally, there’s the Royal collection, which combines sporty and formal elements with integrated bracelets, offering a great alternative to higher-priced luxury models. 

While Tudor’s range may not be as extensive as Longines’, it’s easier to navigate. However, you’ll find fewer options in terms of sizes, case shapes, and dial configurations, which could be a deciding factor if you like a lot of variety. 

Design

Tudor Black Bay

When it comes to design, Longines puts a lot of its focus on elegance and versatility. The brand has mastered the art of blending tradition with innovation, creating watches that are both sophisticated and highly functional. Each collection within Longines feels like it tells its own story, often inspired by the brand’s rich history.

Take the Spirit collection, for example. Its vintage-inspired pilot’s watches channel the durability, legibility, and adventurous spirit of Longines’ aviation past.

Then there’s the Master Collection, which exudes refinement with its clean dials, intricate complications, and classic aesthetics. Even their sportier lines, like the HydroConquest, maintain a polished and versatile look, proving that ruggedness doesn’t mean sacrificing style. 

Longines also offers exceptional diversity in design, catering to men and women equally. Whether it’s the elegance of the DolceVita for women or the sporty sophistication of the Conquest for men, there’s a Longines watch for nearly every occasion and personal style. Their ability to balance a rich heritage with modern-day appeal is one of their biggest strengths, making their designs feel as relevant today as they were decades ago. 

Tudor, on the other hand, has a much more focused design philosophy, one that’s rooted in adventure and rugged functionality. While their designs often take cues from Rolex, it’s worth noting that Tudor has carved out its own identity. Their watches are bold, durable, and unapologetically tool-like, yet refined enough to wear every day. 

One of the hallmarks of Tudor’s design DNA is their snowflake hands, a bold, angular design first introduced in the 1960s. These hands have become iconic, giving Tudor watches a unique and recognizable character. 

The Black Bay collection, which is the cornerstone of Tudor’s lineup, perfectly showcases their retro-inspired yet modern style. From the classic Black Bay Fifty-Eight to the GMT models, these designs feel rugged and adventurous while nodding to the golden era of dive watches in the 1950s and 60s. 

Tudor’s Pelagos collection takes this ruggedness to the next level with professional-grade dive watches designed for serious underwater exploration. Meanwhile, the Royal collection brings a more polished side to Tudor, with integrated bracelets and refined dials that appeal to those seeking a touch of luxury.

Build Quality & Materials

Longines Spirit Zulu Time Black Dial 39mm on Leather Strap

Longines isn’t afraid to experiment with different techniques and materials. They primarily use 316L stainless steel for their collections, especially those in their Sports collection, since these watches need to be highly resistant to corrosion and impacts. 

That said, Longines confidently incorporates luxurious metals like 18-karat gold into many of their models, particularly their dress watches. The use of both yellow and rose gold, often in the form of solid cases or plating, adds a touch of luxury to their offerings.

 Longines has also made use of advanced ceramics, a material often found on their dive watches’ bezels. Ceramic is highly scratch-resistant, adding a layer of sophistication and resilience, especially for models meant for more rugged activities. 

Another common material in Longines’ material palette is titanium, a lightweight yet highly durable material that has found its place in popular models like the Spirit Titanium Automatic.

When it comes to finishing, Longines excels in delivering a predominantly polished aesthetic, particularly in their dress watches. Their polished surfaces reflect light beautifully, giving the watch a refined, high-shine look. In their sportier collections, like the Conquest and HydroConquest, Longines utilizes both polished and brushed finishes to maintain a balance of elegance and toughness.

Tudor takes a more utilitarian approach to watchmaking, focusing on rugged durability and function. The brand predominantly uses 316L stainless steel for its cases, offering the same corrosion resistance and impact resistance as Longines. 

However, Tudor’s use of stainless steel is often paired with brushed finishes, becoming something of a hallmark of their more tool-oriented designs. This technique gives their watches a distinctive, matte texture that complements their no-nonsense aesthetic, especially in collections like the Black Bay. 

In addition to stainless steel, Tudor has used bronze in some of its models, such as the Black Bay Bronze. Bronze has a unique ability to develop a patina over time, allowing each watch to acquire a personalized look. 

This material choice speaks to Tudor’s history of designing watches for adventurers and divers, with bronze being a classic material used in maritime equipment like ships’ propellers and diver’s helmets. 

Tudor has also embraced titanium in the Pelagos line and solid gold in select models like the Black Bay 18k Gold. However, Tudor’s use of gold is relatively minimal compared to other brands, as the focus remains on their core tool-watch ethos.

Movements

Since Longines is part of the Swiss Watch Group, the very same company that owns the famous ETA movement manufacturer, it makes sense that many of Longines’ watches are powered by ETA calibers.

These calibers are highly respected in the watchmaking industry and used by almost every watch manufacturer and their dog. They are well-known for their reliability, precision, and affordability. 

While they might not carry the same level of exclusivity as in-house calibers, they are incredibly well-engineered and have been tested in countless timepieces over the years.

Longines’ use of ETA movements enables the brand to offer exceptional value by keeping their prices more accessible without sacrificing quality or performance.

In fact, many Longines watches, particularly those in their Sport and Aviation collections, come with Chronometer-certified ETA movements, ensuring a high level of accuracy, just like Tudor’s offerings. 

For watch lovers who want a beautifully crafted Swiss timepiece at a more accessible price point, Longines’ use of ETA movements makes sense. 

These movements are incredibly reliable and widely recognized and have been used in numerous prestigious watches across different brands. This also means they have access to a wide number of complications, too, from moonphase and GMT to even complex perpetual calendars.

Tudor’s commitment to in-house movements is one of the defining aspects of the brand. Since its resurgence in 2012, Tudor has been moving away from off-the-shelf calibres and has focused on developing its own proprietary movements, made in partnership with Kenissi, a movement manufacturer co-owned by Tudor. By using these movements, Tudor can ensure that each piece is designed, crafted, and tested to meet their exacting standards. 

A key benefit of Tudor’s in-house movements is their Chronometer certification. For a movement to be Chronometer-certified, it must pass rigorous testing by the Swiss Official Chronometer Testing Institute (COSC), ensuring it meets a high standard of accuracy, usually within -4 to +6 seconds per day. This level of precision is something that collectors and watch enthusiasts deeply appreciate, making Tudor watches a go-to for those who care about accuracy. 

Tudor is not stopping at Chronometer certification either. The brand is gradually moving towards Master Chronometer certification, which is an even more stringent level of testing, further elevating the precision of their watches.

This upgrade marks an exciting development for the brand and ensures that Tudor continues to push the envelope when it comes to technical excellence. 

But because they make their movements in-house, it does mean they are a little more limited to the different complications on offer, especially compared to Longines. Currently, Tudor only uses time-only, GMT and chronograph complications, with no overly complex mechanisms like perpetual calendar or moonphase in sight.

Price Point

When it comes to value for money, Longines delivers. The brand offers many timepieces at significantly lower price points than Tudor yet doesn’t skimp on quality. Take the Longines Spirit, for example. 

Priced around $2,500, it provides a similar look and feel to the Tudor Black Bay Fifty-Eight, but at a much more affordable price. Although Longines relies on ETA movements (which are reliable and well-established), you’re still getting a beautifully crafted Swiss watch at an excellent price.

Longines also has some higher-end pieces, like their solid gold Master Collection, which retail for around $15,000. That’s a far more accessible price than Tudor’s solid gold models, which can climb as high as $32,000. 

Tudor, on the other hand, carries a higher price tag, but there’s a good reason for it. Tudor Black Bay Fifty-Eight is one of the brand’s iconic models, retailing for around $4,500. 

What you’re paying for is the in-house movement, which is chronometer-certified for accuracy, and the company’s heritage linked with the legend of Rolex. It really depends on what you value and what you think is worth the money.

Conclusion 

Choosing between Longines and Tudor ultimately comes down to your personal preferences and what you value most in a watch. Longines offers a fantastic blend of heritage, affordability, and solid quality, making it an excellent choice for those seeking elegance and reliability at a great price.

On the other hand, Tudor brings in-house craftsmanship and precision to the table along with a more rugged, adventure-ready style. Honestly, both brands deliver exceptional value, and I’m certain that whichever you choose, you won’t be disappointed.

tudor vs breitling

With so many impressive watch brands out there, it’s not always easy to know where to start. They all offer something different: different designs, materials, technologies, and totally different price points. But of course, there are some names that stick out more than others, and two of the biggest ones in my eyes are Tudor and Breitling.

These two luxury brands are known all over the world, and yet they’re also worlds apart in what they offer and the people they attract. Tudor, with its understated charm and rich heritage, is famously tied to Rolex and focuses on timeless design and accessible luxury. 

bot-only-imagebot-only-image

Breitling, on the other hand, exudes boldness and adventure and is known for its robust pilot and dive watches that are as functional as they are stylish. Different strokes for different folks, right?

That doesn’t mean one’s better than the other. It all boils down to what you’re looking for in a timepiece. In this blog, we’re going to be looking into both brands to help you figure it all out.

From their fascinating histories to their current collections, movements, and design DNA, I’ll break it all down for you. By the end, you’ll have a clearer picture of which brand aligns with your taste, lifestyle, and budget.

Brand Heritage

Tudor Black Bay 54

For Breitling, we need to go back quite far to 1884. Here, in a small Swiss town called Saint-Imier, a young watchmaker named Léon Breitling opened a modest workshop. 

He began building watches with a focus on precision, innovation, and elegance, and even early on, the company became known for pushing boundaries. Léon’s passion for accuracy and his inventive mindset laid the foundation for a brand that would become a giant in the world of horology. 

Breitling started out specializing in chronographs, tools that went beyond simply telling the time. These early creations played crucial roles in industries like science and engineering and helped make Breitling synonymous with precision. The brand’s commitment to excellence caught on quickly, and it didn’t take long for its reputation to spread far beyond the Alps. 

As aviation took off, literally and figuratively, Breitling became the go-to name for pilots needing accurate, reliable timepieces. In 1915, they introduced one of the first wrist-worn chronographs designed for aviators, and in 1952, the iconic Navitimer was born. 

With its slide rule bezel for in-flight calculations, it became an indispensable cockpit tool, earning its place as one of the most legendary pilot’s watches in the watchmaking world.

But Breitling didn’t stop at aviation. In 1957, they dove into the deep blue with the launch of the SuperOcean, a rugged, water-resistant instrument for divers.

Later decades brought even more innovations, like the Emergency watch in 1995, featuring a built-in distress beacon, and the Chronomat, a luxury sports watch for those who wanted beauty and durability. 

Today, Breitling stands as a symbol of innovation and adventurous spirit. Its collections, from the aviation-inspired Navitimer to the ocean-ready SuperOcean and the versatile Chronomat, reflect a brand deeply rooted in history while embracing modernity.

Established in 1926, Tudor’s story is intricately tied to the vision of Hans Wilsdorf, the founder of Rolex. From its inception, Tudor was designed to echo Rolex’s renowned quality and reliability while being accessible to a broader audience. This duality—luxury craftsmanship at an attainable price—became the bedrock of Tudor’s identity. 

Tudor’s origins trace back to the Swiss watchmaking house of Veuve de Philippe Hüther, which registered the name “Tudor” on behalf of Hans Wilsdorf. Wilsdorf, inspired by his English heritage, chose the Tudor name as a tribute to the Tudor period in England, a time synonymous with strength and refinement. 

Tudor’s first wristwatches, launched in 1932, were simple yet resilient. These timepieces bore a clear emphasis on durability and legibility, featuring cream-colored dials, luminescent Arabic numerals, and blue baton hands. By 1946, Tudor had evolved into Montres TUDOR S.A., with Rolex’s backing for movement precision and distribution. 

The Tudor Oyster, released in 1947, remains one of the brand’s most iconic launches. It borrowed Rolex’s patented waterproof Oyster case as proof of their commitment to robust engineering.

The Oyster Prince followed in 1952, combining reliability with an elegant three-link bracelet, further solidifying Tudor’s appeal as a tool watch for professionals and adventurers. 

The 1960s saw Tudor perfect its design language with the introduction of the legendary “Snowflake” hands and square hour markers. Initially developed for the French Marine Nationale, these features prioritized underwater visibility and became a hallmark of Tudor’s dive watches. 

While Tudor’s popularity waned slightly during the quartz crisis of the 1980s and 1990s, the 21st century marked a dramatic resurgence. Tudor returned to its roots, embracing its legacy of robust tool watches while incorporating modern aesthetics and technology. 

For example, the Black Bay collection, launched in 2012, epitomizes this renaissance, offering modern features, in-house movements, and 200-meter water-resistant cases for the contemporary diver. Today, you also have models like the Pelagos and Ranger embodying Tudor’s ethos of timeless design rooted in history.

Model Variety

Breitling History

Breitling excels in offering something for everyone, with an impressive range of watches designed for various wrist sizes, preferences, and lifestyles. From the petite 28mm Chronomats to the bold 48mm Super Avengers, Breitling ensures that every wrist, no matter how large or small, can find its perfect fit. 

Breitling’s portfolio spans dress watches, pilot’s watches, dive watches, and even vintage-inspired designs. The Navitimer is arguably Breitling’s most recognizable model, embodying the brand’s strong aviation heritage. 

Since its debut in 1952, this iconic pilot’s watch has been a reliable tool for mid-flight calculations, thanks to its distinctive slide-rule bezel. Over the years, the Navitimer has evolved with modern twists but remains a symbol of precision and practicality.

For diving enthusiasts, Breitling’s SuperOcean collection is a standout. Introduced in 1957, it offers water-resistant durability, luminescent hands, and rugged construction suitable for both professional divers and recreational underwater adventures. The retro-inspired SuperOcean Heritage, launched in 2007, adds a sporty yet nostalgic touch to the lineup.

Breitling’s Chronomat collection is a personal favorite of mine and offers versatility with its functional chronograph complications and integrated Rouleaux bracelets, giving it a distinct flair. This line is particularly popular with women thanks to the many pastel-coloured and diamond-set dials adding an element of sophistication. 

Tudor, while less expensive than Breitling, has a focused collection that emphasizes quality over quantity. Their offerings are slightly smaller in scale, with models ranging from 31mm to 43mm, but the brand makes up for it with an emphasis on craftsmanship and purpose-driven design.

At the heart of Tudor’s lineup is the iconic Black Bay collection, a series of diving and tool watches that encapsulate the brand’s expertise in robust and legible timepieces. 

The Black Bay’s roots trace back to Tudor’s first diver’s watch in 1954, and its legacy is evident in features like the signature snowflake hands. From standard Black Bay divers with 200-meter water resistance to the Pelagos models boasting an impressive 500m, Tudor’s commitment to the diving community is clear.

For those seeking a more refined aesthetic, Tudor offers the Royal collection, which bridges the gap between sporty and luxurious. With integrated bracelets, diamond indices, and sizes ranging from a dainty 28mm to a commanding 41mm, the Royal is a versatile option for both men and women.

Tudor hasn’t forgotten about its female clientele either. The Clair de Rose collection, introduced in 2017, is a line of steel automatic watches that exude feminine charm. 

For adventurers, the Ranger and compact Pelagos 39 cater to those who appreciate rugged performance in smaller, versatile packages.

The Pelagos 39, for instance, reimagines Tudor’s dive watch heritage with a sleeker design and updated movement, making it ideal for those who want understated sophistication.

Design

Breitling Watches 2

Breitling’s design DNA is deeply rooted in adventure, precision, and functionality. From the beginning, the brand has been a pioneer in producing watches that serve a practical purpose, and this focus has remained central throughout its history. 

Whether it’s for pilots, divers, or extreme adventurers, Breitling’s watches are designed to withstand the harshest conditions while maintaining cutting-edge style.

Breitling’s designs are bold, often oversized, and purpose-built, making them instantly recognizable. The brand is particularly famous for its aviation-inspired designs, like the iconic Navitimer with its slide-rule bezel. 

Breitling’s watches are known for their large, legible dials, prominent bezels, and functional complications that cater to professionals, such as chronographs, GMTs, and tachymeters.

The Chronomat collection, for instance, exemplifies Breitling’s innovative design with its rider tabs on the bezel and integrated bracelets that balance robustness with elegance.

Meanwhile, Tudor’s design is more of a reflection of its deep-rooted history and heritage, with its designs often paying homage to iconic Rolex models like the Submariner. 

They are famed for their tool-watch pedigree, and like its sibling brand Rolex, the designs strike a balance between luxury and durability. They’re also versatile and functional, often made with military, diving, and adventure enthusiasts in mind, but always with an emphasis on quality craftsmanship and timeless style.

Tudor’s Black Bay collection, for example, exemplifies this blend of ruggedness and heritage. The Black Bay’s design is inspired by vintage Tudor dive watches, especially the submariner-style cases and rotatable bezels reminiscent of models from the 1950s. 

But Tudor also introduced its Snowflake hands in the Black Bay collection, a distinct design element that sets it apart from its competitors, evoking a sense of utilitarian elegance.

The Snowflake hands are a direct nod to the brand’s military and diving roots, offering better legibility underwater, a signature feature that speaks to Tudor’s functional design philosophy.

Build Quality & Materials

Breitling has long been at the forefront of innovation when it comes to the materials used in their timepieces, making sure that each watch balances durability, aesthetics, and functionality.

Their case materials showcase a commitment to both strength and sophistication. Stainless steel is the backbone of many of their collections, but Breitling has expanded its use of premium alloys to include gold, titanium, and even ceramic for specific models.

This ensures their timepieces are not only visually striking but can endure the rigorous demands of adventure, aviation, and diving.

One of Breitling’s standout material innovations is Breitlight. This patented material is a unique, lightweight composite that is stronger than titanium and much lighter than steel, providing impressive resistance to scratches, corrosion, and extreme temperatures. 

The result is a timepiece that feels significantly lighter on the wrist while remaining highly durable. Breitlight also has a distinctive matte finish and a darker, almost “stealthy” look, which contributes to the brand’s modern aesthetic.

When it comes to finishes, Breitling’s attention to detail is evident in the intricate polishing and brushing of their cases. Their dials are also beautifully finished, often made from brass plates, which are drilled and then polished or lacquered to achieve a specific color and depth.

Tudor’s approach to materials and build quality is centered around affordability without sacrificing luxury. One of the most popular materials that Tudor uses is 316L stainless steel, a standard in the watch industry for its resistance to corrosion, scratch resistance, and ability to hold finishes over time.

However, Tudor doesn’t shy away from pushing boundaries. The Black Bay 58 18K is a perfect example of this, as it’s the first Tudor diver’s watch to feature solid 18-carat yellow gold.

Additionally, Tudor has ventured into titanium and ceramic for select models, offering a range of materials that cater to those looking for high-end aesthetics with practical functionality.

Tudor also places significant emphasis on finishing, ensuring their watches are both refined and resilient. The brand often utilizes a mix of brushed and polished surfaces, with an emphasis on creating a visually dynamic and tactile feel.

The sunray brushed finish, commonly found on the Black Bay’s dials, catches the light in an appealing way, while the matte dials add a modern, understated touch.

Movements 

Breitling’s commitment to in-house movement production is a cornerstone of the brand’s identity, offering COSC-certified chronometers across their entire collection. One of Breitling’s best-known movements is the B01, which boasts a 70-hour power reserve and chronograph complication.

Breitling also demonstrates an impressive ability to push the boundaries of horology with haute horlogerie complications, such as perpetual calendars and split-second chronographs, though these are rare and often featured in limited-edition models.

We also have to mention Breitling’s famous SuperQuartz movement, another in-house caliber that is quartz-powered and claims to be ten times more accurate than ordinary quartz.

In terms of movement finishing, Breitling showcases the technical complexity of its calibers with the use of perlage and Côtes de Genève stripes. These finishing touches are not just for aesthetic appeal, but they signify the attention to detail and precision that Breitling is known for.

Tudor’s approach to movements is rooted in simplicity and reliability. While Tudor may not offer the same level of technical complexity as Breitling, they excel in providing robust and reliable movements that serve the needs of their customers.

The brand’s focus remains on time-only and chronograph complications but ones that are still chronometer-certified for reliability.

The MT5612 movement found in many of Tudor’s models, such as the Black Bay, is a solid choice, offering a 70-hour power reserve. Similarly, the MT5813 chronograph movement provides a smooth and precise chronograph function, adding a dash of functionality to Tudor’s classic designs.

While Tudor’s movement finishing may not be as elaborate as Breitling’s, the brand does incorporate finishing elements like brushed surfaces and Côtes de Genève on some models.

The movement’s finishing is more modest, reflecting the brand’s focus on offering high-quality, durable watches at an accessible price point without overemphasizing ornate details.

Price Point 

Breitling’s price range starts at around $3,500 and can rise to $45,000 for high-end models, reflecting the brand’s focus on luxury and prestige.

Their pricing is justified by the use of premium materials like titanium, gold, and Breitlight, alongside in-house movements and sophisticated complications like perpetual calendars and split-seconds chronographs.

Breitling offers exceptional technical innovation and craftsmanship, making their timepieces highly desirable for collectors who want not just a watch but a statement. Their high-end models cater to those seeking exclusivity and prestige in addition to robust functionality, particularly in aviation and diving.

Tudor, renowned for being the king of affordable luxury, offers exceptional value, with prices starting around £2,500 for models like the 1926 and Royal and going up to $9,000 for more premium options with diamond decorations or 18ct gold elements.

Tudor delivers Swiss-made quality, in-house movements, and timeless design at a fraction of the cost of luxury counterparts. While their materials are more conventional, like stainless steel and titanium, they offer incredible value for money, making Swiss precision and affordable luxury accessible.

Conclusion

Both Tudor and Breitling offer exceptional timepieces, but it’s clear they cater to different tastes and budgets. Tudor is perfect for those seeking affordable luxury, delivering Swiss craftsmanship and reliable performance at a more accessible price.

On the other hand, Breitling is ideal for collectors looking for premium materials, advanced complications, and a luxury experience with more opulent designs. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and budget: Tudor offers great value, while Breitling delivers prestige and sophistication.

tudor black bay 54 vs 58

Tudor is one of the most versatile watch brands today, offering something for everyone. They’ve listened to collectors and created models that meet our expectations. Two of their most popular models are the Black Bay 58 and Black Bay 54. Both are best-sellers and play a huge role in Tudor’s success.

Both watches are competitively priced, with only a hundred-dollar difference between them. The Black Bay 58 was released in 2018 and has been an instant hit, remaining popular to this day. 

bot-only-imagebot-only-image

The Black Bay 54 debuted in 2023, quickly gaining its own following, and the two have been competing ever since. Both are highly sought after and loved by the watch community. From photos or at a quick glance, it can be tough to tell them apart, but there are enough differences to make choosing between them a challenge. 

If, like me, you find it hard to decide, comparing these two similar yet different watches can be overwhelming. Let’s break it down to help you decide.

The Tudor Black Bay 54

Tudor Black Bay 54

The Black Bay 54 is named after the year Tudor released its first dive watch in 1954. This model is a modern version of the original Tudor 7922. It keeps the same 37mm case size as the original but improves the water resistance from 100 meters to 200 meters. When you compare the BB54 to the 7922 that inspired it, the two look almost identical. This design gives the BB54 a true vintage feel without using the fake patina that many other watches rely on.

Inside, the BB54 features the MT5400 movement, which is used in other Tudor models like the BB58. This movement is COSC-certified for accuracy, running at minus 2 to plus 4 seconds per day, and it has an impressive 70-hour power reserve. This means you can leave it unworn for a weekend, and it will still keep perfect time when you pick it up again on Monday on your way to work.

The BB54 comes in only one color, black, and is available with either a steel bracelet or a black rubber strap. Both options include the T-fit adjustment clasp, which allows you to fine-tune the bracelet for maximum comfort without needing any tools. It also features a unidirectional rotatable bezel with a 60-minute timer.

The Tudor Black Bay 58

Tudor Black Bay 58

The Black Bay 58 takes its inspiration from Tudor’s 1958 dive watch. It has a slightly larger case size at 39mm, which many consider the “sweet spot” for dive watches. This model’s design includes several nods to Tudor’s history, such as the lollipop-shaped second-hand and rose gold accents on the dial and bezel, giving it a vintage feel.

The BB58 uses either the MT5400 or MT5402 movement, both offering the same COSC-certified accuracy and 70-hour power reserve as the BB54. It also features a unidirectional rotatable bezel with a 60-minute timer, a practical detail for divers or anyone who enjoys timing tasks.

What sets the BB58 apart is the variety of dial and case options. The watch is available in multiple colors, including black, blue, green, and taupe. It also comes in various case materials, such as steel, yellow gold, silver, and bronze, offering a wide range of styles to suit different tastes.

Tudor Black Bay 54 vs 58 – How to Choose

While these two watches have their differences, they share several core features that make them equally impressive. Both models offer 200 meters of water resistance, making them suitable for serious diving or serious desk divers. They are both fitted with durable sapphire crystal glass, which is highly scratch-resistant and helps with daily wear over time.

The BB54 and BB58 also share the same MT5400 movement family, providing excellent timekeeping accuracy and a 70-hour power reserve. Both watches have a lug width of 20mm, allowing for easy strap changes to personalize your look. Additionally, their case thicknesses are nearly identical, with only a 0.7mm difference, ensuring both models are slim enough to fit under a shirt cuff.

The Black Bay 58 stands out for its range of choices. It comes in multiple colors and materials, making it ideal for someone who wants options. For instance, if you love blue tones, the BB58 offers a version with a striking blue dial and bezel. In contrast, the Black Bay 54 keeps it simple with a classic black dial, which pairs effortlessly with any outfit.

Another key difference is the clasp design. The BB54 includes the T-fit clasp, which makes adjusting the bracelet incredibly easy and convenient, especially if your wrist size changes throughout the day due to heat or activity. The BB58, on the other hand, has a traditional clasp with three micro-adjustment positions. While functional, it isn’t as quick or flexible as the BB54’s clasp.

Size is another factor that sets these two models apart. The BB58’s 39mm case has a bold presence on the wrist, appealing to those who prefer a slightly larger watch. The BB54’s 37mm case is smaller and more subtle, offering a lightweight, comfortable fit that many will appreciate.

Choosing between these two watches depends on what matters most to you. I would pick the BB54. My 7-inch wrist works well with both sizes, but the T-fit clasp on the BB54 is a game-changer for me. Living in a warm climate, I often need to adjust my bracelet as my wrist swells in the heat, and the BB54 makes this quick and easy.

Conclusion

Both the Black Bay 58 and Black Bay 54 are excellent additions to any watch collection. The BB58 is perfect for someone who values variety, offering multiple colors, materials, and a slightly larger size. On the other hand, the BB54 is ideal if you prefer a simple, classic look and the convenience of an adjustable clasp.

The deciding factor might come down to how the watch fits your lifestyle and personal preferences. Ultimately, the best choice is the one that sparks joy every time you put it on your wrist. Whichever model you choose, you’re going to love it.

To Top